In the mr of the ring Trilogy (Part 2: The two Towers), where do the Elves go after the battle in the Helm"s deep? The following morning once they (Aragorn and also the others) open up the gates and also charge forward, we carry out not see any type of Elves (the ones who were commanded through Haldir). In the movie it"s the step right before when Gandalf shows up v Eomer and the various other riders.

You are watching: Did any elves survive helms deep


*

*

The Elves at Helm"s Deep were a exit from the publication version and were included for some factor by Peter Jackson and his team.

Because of this, castle would have to play a bigger component in an currently pretty expansive story or castle would have to be quietly dropped from the plot.

Perhaps lock filmed a few scenes either around them obtaining wiped out or going home, however it seems that castle were just dropped in the hope that nobody would certainly notice.


*

I think we deserve to safely assume that all the Elves died during the fight. They take it the complete brunt of the Urak-hai army on the ground after ~ the wall surface was destroyed.

Let"s not forget, that their command (the only Elf who might have approve a retreat) was Haldir - and he died.

The Elves space fiercely well trained and also proud fighters, the is no surprised at all that they battled til death, rather of retreating come the keep.


*

In the book, the elves native Lothlorien to be not connected in this battle. A couple of days ~ the battle of Helm"s Deep, orcs indigenous Dol Guldur swarmed right into the forest of Lothlorien in a full-scale assault. They were repulsed by the power of the elves and Galadriel’s ring.

I assume that in the movie, elves who survived the fight of Helm"s Deep, immediately returned come Lothlorien to protect their forest.


*

Just to be clear, i am right now watching the extended/special version of The 2 Towers. Therefore the key reason the elves, if any survived, did not ride out with Aragorn and also Theoden, merely put, lock didn"t have sufficient horses left. You must remember that the elves arrived at foot no on horseback. It would certainly be safe to believe that any remaining elves stayed in the store to defend the enntrance gate to the caves. Then as soon as the forest finished off the Uruks they could safely return your own forest to assist defend your home. This is of course every educated guesswork of one old Tolkien fan that only comes to the movie, since as was already pointed out in the book the elves were never ever at Helms Deep.


well in the movie i could see some elves to run trough this round arch door thing and then in the direction of an enntrance gate so i simply assume castle left helmsdeep after the battle (Not filmed) to go to valinor or whereby all the elfs went when they left this middle earth lands. :) however thats just how i as with to view the end of the elfs.....

See more: What Does Piss And Vinegar Mean, Where Does The Term Piss & Vinegar Originate From


All that the elves that went to Helm"s Deep were killed in the battle. The critical shot where any elves are seen is when the Uruk-Hai breach the main gate and also begin flooding right into the inner courtyard together Aragorn and also Theoden try to gain as plenty of men as they can into the throne room. No elves room seen running right into the Throne room and the next shot the helms deep reflects that the Uruk-Hai have finish control of the Castle and also are trying to breach the throne room implying that all defenders exterior the room have actually been killed.


You need to log in come answer this question.

Not the answer you're spring for? Browse other questions tagged plot-explanation the-lord-of-the-rings the-two-towers .


site style / logo © 2021 stack Exchange Inc; user contributions license is granted under cc by-sa. Rev2021.11.12.40742


your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, girlfriend agree stack Exchange have the right to store cookie on your an equipment and disclose info in accordance v our Cookie Policy.